Im, G. (2026).
American Psychologist, 81(7), 1048–1059.
As clients increasingly use generative artificial intelligence for emotional support, psychologists now deal with unfamiliar ethical challenges that go beyond conventional risk-management strategies. While generative artificial intelligence systems like ChatGPT or therapy chatbots can be easily accessible, low cost, and oddly compassionate, using them without oversight introduces empirically documented risks such as misinformation and sycophancy, as well as emerging concerns related to cultural bias and potential therapeutic alliance disruption. Drawing from the American Psychological Association (2017) and ethical reflections offered by Chenneville et al. (2024), this conceptual and practice-oriented article applies Crowley and Gottlieb’s (2012) primary risk-management model to build a forward-looking, preventive approach to these new challenges. The primary risk-management model emphasizes five iterative stages: resource accumulation, attention and detection of potential risk, initial appraisal of potential risk, preliminary risk-management efforts, and elicitation and use of feedback. Through conceptual mapping and application to a worst-case illustration, this article shows how primary risk-management model-based prevention can strengthen ethical alertness and reflexive judgment in psychologists facing generative artificial intelligence-related dilemmas. The discussion concludes with suggestions for education, professional policy, and empirical research, all aimed at reinforcing preparedness and reducing predictable harm. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2026 APA, all rights reserved)
Impact Statement
With generative artificial intelligence rapidly entering the mental health landscape, both its accessibility and its potential for error create urgent ethical concerns. This article shows how a prevention-oriented model can equip psychologists to anticipate risks, address misunderstandings, and support clients in navigating artificial intelligence tools safely and responsibly.
Here are some thoughts:
Im (2026) looks at a problem most psychologists now face: patients who use generative AI (genAI) for emotional support on their own, sometimes without telling their psychologist. The article separates this from AI-assisted therapy, where the psychologist chooses to bring AI into treatment. Im describes the benefits, including easy access, low cost, and small but steady effects on depression and anxiety. He also describes the main risks: hallucination, sycophancy, cultural bias from training data, weak privacy protections, and repeated failure to recognize suicide risk or start safety planning.
He then reviews the APA Ethics Code principles and Standards 1.01, 2.01, 2.03, and 3.04. On the tension between autonomy and harm prevention, he sides with Knapp and VandeCreek (2007), who give beneficence and nonmaleficence priority.
The core of the article applies Crowley and Gottlieb’s (2012) primary risk-management model, which has five stages that repeat: building resources, detecting potential risk, making an initial appraisal, starting early risk management, and using feedback. For each stage, Im describes preventive steps for risks caught early and reactive steps for genAI use found late. He illustrates the model with a worst-case vignette. A psychologist who dislikes technology brushes off a lonely international student’s growing reliance on a chatbot, and she is later hospitalized after a suicide attempt. Im’s practical recommendations are to add genAI screening questions at intake, provide psychoeducation, and agree with patients that they will contact a human crisis service, not a chatbot, when suicidal. He also recommends regular check-ins, consultation, and self-care.
Throughout, he stresses that psychologists need to examine how their own views of technology shape their judgment. Im notes that the model has not yet been tested in practice and calls for validated measures of AI-related risk and clear standards for documenting genAI use in records.








